Guide
Editing short fiction
Editing is where a draft becomes a story. The most efficient approach is to work from the largest problems to the smallest, in three separate passes: a structural edit, a line edit, and a proofread. Trying to do all three at once is how writers end up polishing sentences they later cut.
Before you begin: get some distance
The draft you have just finished is still running in your head. You'll read what you meant rather than what you wrote. Before editing:
- Rest the draft. Leave it for at least a few days; a week or more is better.
- Change the format. Print it, change the font, or read it on a different device. Unfamiliar formatting helps you see it fresh.
- Read it once without a pen. Note only your overall response: where you were gripped, where you drifted, what you remember.
Pass one: the structural edit
The structural edit looks at the story as a whole: what it's about, how it's shaped, and whether each part earns its place. Ignore sentences for now.
Make a reverse outline
List every scene or section in order, with one line each describing what happens and what changes. This turns a dense draft into a map you can see at a glance. The story map worksheet works well for this.
Ask the big questions
- What is the story about? Write one sentence about its preoccupation, not its plot. If you can't, that's the first problem to solve.
- Where does it really begin? Many drafts start too early. Look for the first moment of real tension and consider starting there.
- Does every scene turn? Using your reverse outline, mark any scene where nothing changes. Cut it, merge it, or give it a turn.
- Is the turning point clear and placed well? Is the story's central moment given enough space?
- Is the ending earned? Has the story prepared for it? Does it end too late, after the meaning has landed?
- Is the point of view consistent? Check for slips into other characters' heads. Our guide to building characters through perspective shifts covers the options.
- Who is missing, and who is extra? Could two minor characters be combined? Does someone central lack a want of their own?
- What scene haven't you written? Sometimes the story's most important moment happens offstage because it was the hardest to write.
Make structural changes first
Move, cut and add scenes now. This is also the moment to reconsider shape – could this story work better as a braid, or in reverse? Our guide to plot and structure describes a range of options. Then reread the whole story before moving on, because structural changes ripple.
Pass two: the line edit
Once the structure is sound, turn to the prose, paragraph by paragraph and sentence by sentence. The aim is clarity, energy and consistency of voice.
Cut
Most drafts improve when trimmed. Look for:
- Repetition – the same information given twice, or the same word used close together without purpose.
- Throat-clearing – opening sentences in a paragraph that warm up before the real point.
- Over-explanation – lines that tell readers what a scene has already shown.
- Filter words – she saw, he felt, she noticed, he realised – which can often be removed so the reader experiences the thing directly. She saw the gate was open becomes The gate was open.
- Unnecessary qualifiers – very, quite, rather, just, a little, somewhat.
Strengthen
- Verbs. Replace weak verb-plus-adverb pairs with a precise verb: walked slowly might become trudged, ambled or dawdled, each with a different meaning.
- Specifics. Swap general nouns for particular ones where it matters: not a bird but a currawong; not food but cold chips.
- Dialogue. Read every exchange aloud. Cut greetings and small talk unless they do work. Prefer said for attribution, and omit tags where the speaker is clear.
- Sentence rhythm. Vary lengths. Notice runs of sentences that all begin the same way.
Keep the voice
A line edit can flatten a voice. Before changing an unusual word or rhythm, ask whether it is an error or a characteristic. Keep the strangeness that is yours; our guide to finding your voice has more on this.
Getting feedback
After your own structural and line edits, a reader can show you what you can't see. To make feedback useful:
- Choose readers who read the kind of fiction you write.
- Ask specific questions. "Where did you lose interest?" and "What did you think the ending meant?" are more useful than "Did you like it?"
- Listen for patterns. If one reader dislikes something, consider it. If three do, it almost certainly needs work.
- Separate diagnosis from prescription. Readers are often right that something is wrong and less reliable about how to fix it.
Writing groups can be excellent for this; some of the methods in our guide to collaborative storytelling adapt well to feedback sessions.
Pass three: the proofread
Proofreading is the last pass, done only when the words are settled. Its job is to catch errors in spelling, punctuation, grammar, formatting and consistency.
- Proofread separately. Don't combine it with line editing; you'll start rewriting and miss mistakes.
- Read aloud, slowly. Your ear catches what your eye skips.
- Read on paper. Errors that hide on screen often show up in print.
- Try reading backwards, sentence by sentence, to break the pull of the story.
- Keep a style sheet. Note spellings of names and places, how you handle numbers, hyphenation choices, and whether you use single or double quotation marks. Check the story against it.
- Check formatting against any submission guidelines.
Cutting to a word limit
Competitions and magazines often set firm word limits. If your story runs long, cut in the same order as you edit: structure first, sentences second.
- Look for a removable scene or subplot. Losing one scene usually saves far more than trimming fifty sentences, and often sharpens the story.
- Compress summary passages. Background and transitions can often be halved without loss.
- Trim the opening and ending. First and last paragraphs frequently contain warm-up and wind-down.
- Only then cut at sentence level, using the line-edit techniques above.
Resist the temptation to hit the limit by cutting every the and that. A story that has been squeezed rather than shaped reads as breathless.
Knowing when to stop
Stories can be revised forever. Signs you are nearly done:
- Your changes are swapping one acceptable word for another, then back again.
- Readers' remaining comments are matters of taste rather than clarity.
- You can state what the story is about and see every scene serving it.
At that point, let it go out into the world – and start the next one.
Printable self-editing checklist
Print this page or copy the checklist below. Work through it in order, one pass at a time.
Self-editing checklist for short fiction
Story title:
Draft number: Date rested until:
In one sentence, this story is about:
Pass one: structure
- ☐ I have made a reverse outline of every scene.
- ☐ Every scene has a turn – something changes by the end.
- ☐ The story starts at the first moment of real tension.
- ☐ The turning point is clear and given enough space.
- ☐ The ending is prepared for, and doesn't explain itself.
- ☐ Point of view is consistent, with no accidental head-hopping.
- ☐ Each major character wants something specific.
- ☐ I have written any important scene I was avoiding.
Scenes to cut, merge or move:
Pass two: line edit
- ☐ I have cut repetition and over-explanation.
- ☐ I have removed filter words where possible (saw, felt, noticed, realised).
- ☐ I have trimmed unnecessary qualifiers (very, quite, just, rather).
- ☐ Verbs are precise; adverbs are rare and deliberate.
- ☐ Details are specific where it matters.
- ☐ Dialogue reads naturally aloud and tags are minimal.
- ☐ Sentence lengths and openings vary.
- ☐ I have kept the words and rhythms that sound like me.
Words or habits I overuse:
Feedback
- ☐ At least one trusted reader has read the story.
- ☐ I asked them specific questions.
- ☐ I have noted patterns in their responses.
What readers agreed on:
Pass three: proofread
- ☐ Read aloud, slowly, start to finish.
- ☐ Read on paper.
- ☐ Spelling of names and places matches my style sheet.
- ☐ Punctuation of dialogue is consistent.
- ☐ Quotation marks are consistent (single or double).
- ☐ Formatting matches the submission guidelines.
Ready to submit or share? Yes / Not yet
Next step:
If you're editing a remix, add one more check: your attribution statement is complete and accurate. Our guide to remixing a short story includes a template and a licence compliance checklist.